Avalon Pizza (Made From Scratch)

$ 30.00
$ 30.00
Color Heather Maroon


In the 1930s, Avalon Gardens emerged on Belmont Ave post-Prohibition, becoming a cherished eatery in Youngstown. Founded by Gennaro and Lena Massullo, grandparents of Anne Massullo-Sabella, owner of Avalon Downtown Pizzeria, it gained fame for its warm ambiance and exceptional cuisine. After 40 years, the Massullos sold to the Sabellas in 1970, leading to the introduction of iconic Youngstown-style pizzas by Michael Sabella and Robert Smith. This revitalized the restaurant, which closed in 2010 but paved the way for Avalon Downtown Pizzeria on W Federal, carrying forward the tradition. Lorenzo, Anne's son, learned the pizza-making art from Smitty, ensuring the legacy lives on through painstakingly crafted pizzas, made-from-scratch dishes, and a vibrant community atmosphere. Today, Avalon Downtown Pizzeria stands as a symbol of Youngstown's culinary heritage and camaraderie.

A portion of all proceeds will be going to The Joannie Abdu Breast Care Center at St. Elizabeth Hospital.

  • Heather Cranberry
  • 50/50 Blend (50% Polyester / 50% Ring-Spun Cotton) Construction
  • Made in the U.S.A
  • Printed in Youngstown, OH
  • Everything you love about the fit, feel and durability of a vintage T-shirt

Shipping & Returns

Shipping | Cost varies based on weight and destination. Your order will be shipped out within 24 hours of purchase date. Orders over $99 ship free.

Returns | We want you to be 100% satisfied with your purchase. Items can be returned or exchanged within 30 days of delivery. No questions asked.